Please tell me where I said I was a "backup software and ccc" guru. Honestly, I know you take your job of going from thread to thread defending shirtpocket very seriously, and for free, but please try and stick to what I actually said.

As for your question, I haven't had those errors. Others have. Regardless, your question is pointless. You're comparing a piece of software that 'might' have errors that are more serious to a piece of software that doesn't work at all.

I know. Superduper is making sure everything is perfect. Wouldn't help me if my HD crashed today.

Backup software
 

I think with backup software I'd rather know something didn't work than use something that other people have reported errors on that I didn't see myself. The worst situation is thinking you have a good backup and finding out you don't really when your drive dies. Given persistent errors in things like syncing iCal and the address book to .Mac, and a few Leopard crashes, I'm not really sure I trust Time Machine. From my own experiences and looking at the Bombich user forums, I wouldn't necessarily say that CCC really does work better than the betas of SD; but CCC has been released anyway. You can backup documents, settings, and files a variety of ways to cover yourself if you don't rely on one product that turns out to be buggy.